I've been a teacher for 26 years and had major pastoral resposibilities for 10 of them. I'm also the father of three bright and successful teenagers. Without doubt, the issue of yobbish or thuggish behaviour - which started this thread - is a complex one. My experience has taught me that a large part of it is an individual being taught restraint, by a significant elder figure, whether that be parent, relative, religious representative or teacher.
How the restraint is experienced will differ from person to person; I appreciate that preventative legislation to stop domestic violence is a good thing, the NSPCC has perhas less to do as a result. BUT... somehow, the concept of "conseqences" (of an unpleasant nature) must be brought home to a young person and the younger the better. Who amongst us, as parents, has not experienced "the terrible twos"? If a young person learns that there are no "consequences", they progress, to greater or lesser extents, to 'buck the rules'. I see this daily, and I work in a GOOD school, not one in an inner-city, declining, unemployment 'hotspot'.
Political correctness has done us no favours over the last two decades. It seems to have been coupled to a total lack of foresight as to how blanket legislation could influence events and create further problems. Don't get me wrong; I have seen enough human misery within families to realise something had to be done to protect the vulnerable, but there is SO much cossetting beyond the necessary that the ungodly have quickly learned to manipulate said restrictive legislation to suit themselves and pander to their own unrestricted hedonism.
This is going to sound like the Ayatollah speaking, but I for one would like to see a return to a more rigorous society. I too was caned and clipped round the ear as a schoolboy, but I am sure I would not recommend we return to physical torture as a "consequence". Instead, why not 'work experience' of a quite different nature? Drain clearing, rubbish sorting, lavatory cleaning, farm labouring, road digging? And, why on earth should prison be SUCH a cushy number? It costs me as a taxpayer what, 10-100, 000£ per prisoner, per year? Phone cards, central heating, regular meals? Just as soon as EVERY Goverment minister can show me that EVERYchild in Britain can enjoy the same benefits, THEN we can give these perks back to prisoners. I am not Utopian, but I will claim more common sense than the goody-two-shoes, 'social conscience' mutts who are restricting the control of our young and providing endless opportunities to the criminal amongst us.
Honest politicians? Jack Ashley and perhaps Frank Field. Rest of them are a bunch of vote chasers.