Alan Jones":2li9jmyr said:Looking good Tom,I see you have japanese as well as lie nielsen chisels which do you prefer?
Oooh definately the lie nielsens
The japanese ones were moderately cheap from tilgear, so its probably a slightly unfair comparison - I'd like to try some decent ones as well at some point. They do hold a really good edge, but I had problems with the edges being too fragile. I managed to fix this by honing a 35 degree angle, and grinding back a few mm. I read somewhere that often the very edges of a brand new chisel is more brittle because it cools quicker, so its normal to have to remove it. I quite like them for chopping - the iron hoop means I'm not shy about whacking it with my japanese hammer.
They're not as nice to hold for paring though, and the sides of the smaller chisels are pretty much 90 degrees, which can make it awkward for chopping dovetails.
The lie nielsens on the other hand are lovely to use for paring and fit perfectly in my hand. According to LN they test them with a framing hammer, but I'm always too scared to use anything other than a small brass carving mallet.
My plan is to try and build up a collection, but at 50 quid a pop, its not easy! The Aka-Kashi chisels were about 40 quid for 4, which I reckon is a bargain for anyone starting out or looking to try japanese chisels.