Ledge door

[meccarroll]

Thanks for the advice! What's the argument for clenching with the grain as opposed to across the grain? I was worried about splitting, and I thought it would be stronger perpendicular to the grain, but that was just my guess.

Otherwise, I did my best to embed them into the ledges. I wacked them hard with a lump hammer and a 5mm piece of steel as an anvil against the nail head. These nails are VERY stout and not easy to clench.

The door you have made looks very nice but clenching with the grain allows the nails to sink in to the wood slightly. I would tend to knock the end in first a little then flatten the rest of the nail down a little so there is no hook created by the nails to snag clothes. Take a look next time you are in a Historic building or even a ironmonger's that has ledge and braced doors.

 

[thetyreman]

I have the same book doormaking and window making, it's recommended that you add diagonal bracing, I'm wondering why you didn't do this?

 

[AJBaker]

I have the same book doormaking and window making, it's recommended that you add diagonal bracing, I'm wondering why you didn't do this?

He recommends bracing if it's wider than 2'6", but my door is just under that and fairly lightweight since it's out of pine.
I thought of maybe bracing it anyway in case it needed it, but sagging has thankfully not been a problem on this door.

 

[AJBaker]

The door you have made looks very nice but clenching with the grain allows the nails to sink in to the wood slightly. I would tend to knock the end in first a little then flatten the rest of the nail down a little so there is no hook created by the nails to snag clothes. Take a look next time you are in a Historic building or even a ironmonger's that has ledge and braced doors.

Thanks!
Not many doors with clenched nails around here, unfortunately. Historically, I think that nails were more expensive here than in the UK, so they weren't used as often. Most interior and front doors I've come across have been a variation of a four panel door, and ledge doors were mostly for shutters or cellars/barns. They mostly seem to be made from two (very wide) boards, and instead of being nailed on, the ledges are inserted into the boards with a sliding dovetail.

 

[johnnyb]

ive seen some batten doors move over an inch. Even a small amount is a pain tbh. But your door looks the business. Can you adjust the hinges a bit so it claps to better.?

 

[AJBaker]

ive seen some batten doors move over an inch. Even a small amount is a pain tbh. But your door looks the business. Can you adjust the hinges a bit so it claps to better.?

Thanks!
How would I go about that? This is my first time making and hanging a door.
The hinges are big 18" strap hinges.

 

[JSW]

You could try putting it in purgatory, @Sgian Dubh posted about this Here, I've done this in the past, sometimes it works, but usually only short term.

Other than that, move the stop lath and threshold over to meet the doors twist on the clapping side

BTW, are those worm holes in the threshold?