By toxic do you mean inclusions of larger abrasive particles? Not up on razor speak! I would expect your CF to get considerably finer than a Washita but then you are only honing the secondary on it so it should give you a good edge. The CFs I have are very fine and put a good sharp edge on my Japanese chisels at least as good as a Sigma 13K, however the finish does look different with the hagane being revealed more.