ByronBlack":q04iqedh said:
I also woudn't describe Milner as a proper winger - certainly not on the left anyway, his best position by his own admission is on the right side or middle.
I'm being overly critical, but its so frustrating to see Capello go against his own statements "I will only take fit players, I will only pick players on form" - both of which are complete boulderdash as he reverts back to the same old choices that have never worked in the past.
That's a fair comment on Milner. I just meant that he's far better suited to that role than Gerrard
- and Wright-Phillips, based on tonight's performance!
Of all, the managers we've had since Glenn Hoddle was sacked, Capello is the only one I've had any faith in - and I'm quite the xenophobe when it comes to managing a national side!!
You're right; our first eleven isn't that different to the team we were fielding eight or nine years ago - yet, look at how just about every other nation has changed considerably. That's where my sceptical side kicks in, with a suspicion that the FA (no to mention the media) have more of a say in team selection for its highest "commercial value" or whatever.... :?
Tonight's game showed a lot of promise and, of the three games I've seen of this World Cup so far, it was the most entertaining, to me. Heskey didn't do too badly and the Gerrard/Lampard combination seemed to work quite well... Yet, we only managed the one goal? I don't think we can heap too much praise on Tim Howard. As much as that was an improvement over past performances, we're still clearly lacking 'something'.
Fair credit to Heskey, though. He didn't do badly at all. Despite what I said about him earlier on, I was a huge fan when he was at Leicester. Then, he moved to Anfield and it all seemed to start going wrong - he lost his centre of gravity and everything!
I thought things may have picked up again at Birmingham or Wigan but, not really. He's a confidence player; in the sense that, when he doesn't believe in himself, he doesn't perform at all (where as, other players in the same situation can still make some contribution to a team effort). I never rated Gerard Houllier (Benitez Mk.I) as a manager so, I can't imagine he helped Heskey' self esteem. I was pleased to see him reunited with O'Neill at Villa though, I still fear it could be too late for his career (regardless of tonight's performance).
We all know, deep down, that he can do the job and we always have... That's the reason he's been back in contention (coupled with the memories of that 5-1 victory in Germany, years ago! :wink
I think it's safe to say we'll make it past the group stages.
I used see Alan Smith as another contender for the no.9 jersey but, what the heck happened to him?! He seemed to drop of the face of the Earth... ?
No, wait! He joined
Newcastle, didn't he!!
That clubs a curse for just about every player. It's like crash landing on the LOST island! James Milner is only one of only a small handful of players (Shay Given being the other) to have joined and left them without harming his career. Obafemi Martins, Geremi, Mark Viduka, Michael Owen, Stephen Carr, Celestine Babayaro... (A few of the more recent names I can remember) They were all pretty good - until they joined Newcastle! Where are they now???