The Joinery Bench

[wizer]

I just saw this on Chris Shwarz blog. It's a great idea. I think workbenches are too low, even for average height people without back problems. You may be reluctant to raise the bench height, but if you have the room you could have one of these:

http://blog.woodworking-magazine.com/bl ... +Come.aspx

 

[Shultzy]

Too low for me Wizer, my workbench is 39" already :lol:. I have back problems and this height doesn't give me any gip.

 

[George_N]

I'm reading Chris Schwartz's workbench book at the moment. In the book he proposes 34" as the optimum height for hand tool work (I think he's 6'3"), the reasoning being, that you can get your full weight bearing down when planing, which you wouldn't be able to do if your arms are bent significantly. He goes on to say that if you mainly use wooden planes, the bench should be 31" high because the plane bodies are around 3" deep. It looks from the blog like he has had a bit of a re-think. I guess that those heights may be fine if you prepare all your stock from rough sawn by hand but a 31" high bench would have me bent double.

 

[Chems]

My saw bench is 33 inchs and this is the first surface I've had which I can plan on. My main bench was built before I got into woodworking and is pretty high, talking 45inch at a guess. Its great for hand routing and bits but can't do any planning as my arms get worn out as they are above heart level. But that once is coming out over the coming weeks to be replaced by a Robou so one of these would be ideal. So ideal actually I may just start one tomorrow!

 

[ondablade]

I guess height for planing, versus height for chisel work is the question - how to accommodate what are essentially separate requirements.

Two possible disadvantages of this approach that strike me are that they seem likely to (a) result in lighter individual benches that are more likely to move about in use, and (b) to entail some walking backwards and forwards between benches

 

[houtslager]

you could always make a secondary bench to sit on top of your "planing" bench to allow you to do chisel work or detsil work. This generally was a simple open box about 10" high

hth

hs

 

[Chris Knight]

you could always make a secondary bench to sit on top of your "planing" bench to allow you to do chisel work or detsil work. This generally was a simple open box about 10" high

hth

hs

As has been extensively discussed here in the past with several members having made one..

 

[Steve Maskery]

He says:

I can minimize my suffering ... by using a wider stance when sawing. Placing your feet farther apart lowers your torso, so you don't have to bend as much.

Crikey, I haven't done the math (sic) but just how far apart does he stand to make any significant drop in COG of his body?

S

 

[Harbo]

I have had a similar device for years - made from one of the original wooden topped Workmates
Not as sophisticated, but fitted with two Record Holdfast sockets and it folds for storage. I can even fasten my small portable Record metal vice on it too and the feet can be adjusted for uneven surfaces.

Rod

 

[wizer]

you could always make a secondary bench to sit on top of your "planing" bench to allow you to do chisel work or detsil work. This generally was a simple open box about 10" high

hth

hs

As has been extensively discussed here in the past with several members having made one..

Including myself. I actually made my bench to just under elbow height (I'm 6'2"). So I got rid of the Benchtop Bench. I've no intention of ever doing extensive planing, so the 'joinery bench' is my standard every day bench. Just thought it was an interesting idea for those who do use standard height workbenches.

 

[Benchwayze]

That's a Workmate on steroids!

Nice and neat for sure!

Thinking about it... One could always make a 'supplementary' benchtop. Two full length runners underneath. One runner gripped in the vice and the other, resting on the bench. The runners would need to be diffferent depths is all.
Or is that crazy?

John

 

[Mr Ed]

I am quite taken with the idea of this, having said that I don't really ever have an issue with using my normal bench for joinery. I mustn't once again fall into the trap of allowing shop improvements to distract from real projects though!

Ed

 

[Chems]

There is a fine balance thou ed, having the right area to work in improves the enjoyment of working 10 fold for me.

 

[Mr Ed]

There is a fine balance thou ed, having the right area to work in improves the enjoyment of working 10 fold for me.

I agree, I could quite happily spend ALL my time improving the workshop and tinkering about with things. I need reminders to start projects, because when I get one started I remember that this is what I actually enjoy.

Ed

 

[Chems]

I find that I spend much more time making projects then they go off to their owners and I have no physical reward for my work, but with workshop improvements I get to use it everyday

 

[woodsworth]

Welsh people need benches to

 

[Steve Maskery]

What an excellent way to look at it, Chems. Yes, I like that. Tinkering for pleasure.
S

 

[Shultzy]

I agree Steve, best to be in the workshop making things, a good "stress-buster" :lol: .