Which CNC router for aluminium sheet?

UKworkshop.co.uk

Help Support UKworkshop.co.uk:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Chris152

Established Member
Joined
26 Apr 2017
Messages
3,354
Reaction score
1,071
Location
Cardiff
OK, I think we've focused our minds on a CNC router (after my posts on a printer and then mill conversion in this part of the forum). This is partly to learn cnc, and partly to make some bits for motorcycle modifications using 2mm aluminium sheet.

Making one is beyond us (just to get that out the way!). So it's either buy new or used. The operations are pretty simple/ don't need to be terribly precise. This kind of thing:
IMG_20250122_173443.jpg

(It's to replace a heavy instrument panel/ fairing mount on a bike - 2mm 6082 ally).

I know it's best to find a setup that's not overly flexible, but apart from that have no real idea what to get. Lots of names of manufacturers, different models, different prices. Where to begin?!
The maximum would be £2000 for new, I'd prefer much less, and not sure about what to expect to pay for used (and, presumably a bit outdated?) Realistically, in the long run, if we get on well with what we buy we'd likely upgrade once we've got the hang of things. But equally we don't want something that'll annoy us.

Sooo! Any recommendations?
 
A router works in three dimensions. You have provided only one dimension (2mm) in your specification. The photo of the bent piece you show is very roughly 200mm left to right. Is that the maximum you will ever want? And what of the front-to-back dimension?

Whatever machine you buy, you have to hold the aluminium sheet onto the bed of it before and during machining and then remove it afterwards. Some approaches to solving that issue may have budgetary implications after the initial purchase cost of the machine.
 
Size and rigidity (usually mapping to weight) are important factors. If the parts you want to cut are relatively small (e.g. a work area no bigger than 30x30cm) then you'll likely get away with a fairly budget machine. You can use something like a 1/8" (3mm) single flute spiral cutter and have decent success in 6082T6 ally (without needing mist or flood lubrication). NB I've found other grades of ally (common for sheet goods) to be very "gummy", but 6082 is usually OK.

You'd get something like the Ooznest Workbee (https://ooznest.co.uk/product/original-workbee-z1plus-cnc-machine/#size-colour) in a small size for under £2k; or less used (one on eBay now for £899).

One of the Stepcraft models might also be worth considering (https://shop.stepcraft-systems.com/cnc-construction-kit-d-series).

The Denford Microrouter is reasonable too; but only used, and you need to get one that's been converted to run available control software as the Denford proprietary stuff isn't usually an option.

There are various sub-£500 Chinese machines (e.g. google "3018 cnc") but I'd probably avoid those.
 
You'd get something like the Ooznest Workbee...

Thanks for pointing that one out.

Has anyone remarked here previously that the router motor they offer is a clone of the Makita/Katsu one but with an ER11 spindle?

That means in principle it should fit all standard router bases for those brands and have the ability to take a much wider range of cutters (a full set of ER11 collets is not a lot of money and can be had in 2-7mm as standard, with 8mm, 1/8" and 1/4" also possible).
 
I suggest a second hand industrial machine over a home style machine like a workbee etc.

A smaller machine is easier to keep stiff and that is important.
For metal machining you will probably want coolant and so will need some kind of tank and pump system and chip tray.
This would lean more towards a cnc mill or a fixed gantry style with a moving bed rather than moving gantry.
I would not bother with a trim router as the motor but a proper water cooled spindle, these days they are pretty cheap and worlds better than any router.

You will need to think about what is the biggest thing you will need to machine, how you will hold the material, how will you design the things you want to make and how will you generate the g code.

you can make most older machines work with a new uccnc and an axbb http://shop.cncdrive.com/index.php?productID=1009
 
Thanks all, that's really helpful.
@sploo - 30 x 30cm is plenty for now, if we really need to my lad can weld sections together but that's very unlikely.
@Ollie78 - we've talked about it and can't think of when we might need more than 2mm thickness ally - except when much thicker and then it'll need to be done the old-fashioned way on the mill. (I did look into cnc-ing the mill but it's going to take more time/ effort and probably understanding than I have.)*
The Ooznest ones look nice Sploo - I saw the ebay one, do they usually have cables hanging off the gantry like that? Made in England sounds good, too.

eta *I forgot to write my question, Ollie. Do you think 2mm aluminium will be too much for the Ooznest style kit?
 
Last edited:
For metal machining you will probably want coolant...

On 2mm aluminium, on a machine in the class of those shown above, coolant could be a great disbenefit.

With the chip size and volume that such a machine can produce, either a light air blast or a vacuum extraction will suffice. A solid wax lubricant applied to the outline of the part would be another alternative.

Liquid coolant is likely to produce a silver coloured slurry that will be quite challenging to manage.
 
On 2mm aluminium, on a machine in the class of those shown above, coolant could be a great disbenefit.

With the chip size and volume that such a machine can produce, either a light air blast or a vacuum extraction will suffice. A solid wax lubricant applied to the outline of the part would be another alternative.

Liquid coolant is likely to produce a silver coloured slurry that will be quite challenging to manage.
This is true but I know how these things go.
You will start by doing a bit of 2mm sheet then, you know, since you have a cnc machine you will start making other stuff pretty quick.

This is why I think it is important to decide what you really want to do, not just the first job but the 10th job or 50th job.
 
This is true but I know how these things go.
You will start by doing a bit of 2mm sheet then, you know, since you have a cnc machine you will start making other stuff pretty quick.

This is why I think it is important to decide what you really want to do, not just the first job but the 10th job or 50th job.
It's definitely for up to 2mm aluminium, Ollie.
 
I noticed that the Ooznest ones use a leadscrew. As I said above, it doesn't need the greatest accuracy, just wondering if not being ball screw is an issue?
 
Thanks all, that's really helpful.
@sploo - 30 x 30cm is plenty for now, if we really need to my lad can weld sections together but that's very unlikely.
@Ollie78 - we've talked about it and can't think of when we might need more than 2mm thickness ally - except when much thicker and then it'll need to be done the old-fashioned way on the mill. (I did look into cnc-ing the mill but it's going to take more time/ effort and probably understanding than I have.)*
The Ooznest ones look nice Sploo - I saw the ebay one, do they usually have cables hanging off the gantry like that? Made in England sounds good, too.

eta *I forgot to write my question, Ollie. Do you think 2mm aluminium will be too much for the Ooznest style kit?
Ok as you already have a mill and it is strictly for thin aluminium. I think the ooznest style kit would be capable of cutting it.

However it is my opinion that you still should not buy one unless cheap and second hand.
My issue with the design is mostly the fact that it runs on an aluminium extrusion with wheels. This is a situation asking for trouble with swarf and dust getting in there, and also belts are a possible failure point. The Shapeoko is a slightly better version of the same idea which has some improvements.
The Stepcraft ones are a better.
To be fair the chinese 30/40 ones are possibly better than the ooznest because they use rails and basllscrews, the trouble is more often it the electronics on these and getting a reliable supplier. My mate had a 60/40 one and it was mechanically fine but he had to change it to uccnc which sorted it out.

Roland do some neat small machines similar to the denfords as well, often used in schools and stuff, again software might need updating.
 
I noticed that the Ooznest ones use a leadscrew. As I said above, it doesn't need the greatest accuracy, just wondering if not being ball screw is an issue?
Leadscrews are fine for accuracy purposes and better than belts. The advantage of ballscrews is more the longevity and easy peasy maintanance.
 
The Ooznest ones look nice Sploo - I saw the ebay one, do they usually have cables hanging off the gantry like that? Made in England sounds good, too.
I don't know I'm afraid - I've never used one (I just know of the brand). My CNC machine is ~20 years old, and from a US manufacturer that unfortunately no longer exists.

My machine is (now) fitted with a 3hp spindle, has ballscrews, and weighs around 100kg. However, when using a 1/8" single flute spiral bit the limit is really the deflection on the cutter; not the spindle power. Taking 1mm deep cuts works ok; with a bit of care to clear chips with a vacuum cleaner. It takes a long time, but I have cut shapes from 20mm thick aluminium with success.
 
Back
Top