Tool Review - Bevel edged chisels

UKworkshop.co.uk

Help Support UKworkshop.co.uk:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
A

Anonymous

Guest
http://www.screwfix.com/app/sfd/cat/pro ... &id=35587#

Lets get this straight - I don't use a lot of hand tools. I have a lovely set of Bahco chisels in the workshop bought me by SWMBO as a birthday present a couple of years ago which I keep very nice and shiny (and sharp) by not using very much! My main need for chisels is when I'm out on a job fitting furniture and kitchens, hanging doors etc.

Which is where the Screwfix set comes in.

The first thing you notice is the metal case they come in. This is a very cheap set of chisels made (no doubt) in China but the storage case is absolutely top notch! It's a perfect size for flinging in the tool box at the end of a day's work, is robustly constructed like a mini flight case, and the chisels themselves are held in place by a quality moulded foam rubber insert. Pop this set open in front of your average customer and they are actually quite impressed!

I carefully honed the chisels by eye on my diamond wetstone (not the one included, even to me that looked a little agricultural) and prepared to do battle.

Test 1 - Pencil Sharpening.

This is where I realised that there was actually some quality here! In four or five gentle strokes my humble HB was as sharp as a needle. I was well chuffed. Even better than a brand new stanley knife blade!

Test 2 - Filling

The 1" chisel performed this important test admirably. From the moment I placed the blade under the rim of the can lid I had no doubts. A firm twist of the wrist and the lid flew a good 5 feet across the room. Who says the Chinese can't produce quality goods?

Mixing the filler with the hardener is always a stern test of a chisel, and the Screwfix again passed with flying colours. A nice even paste was achieved in record time, and once applied to the nail holes in the kitchen face-frame I was fitting, the chisel smoothed the filler in beautifully. A quick wipe on the back of my jeans and five minutes later the very same chisel could be used to knock off the excess, now semi-hard, filler to a fine finish. All in all, a first class performance!

Tip - a wire brush attachment to your bench grinder removes dried up filler off your chisels a treat.

Test 3 - Screwdriving

As usual, I had forgotton to take a flat head screwdriver on the job with me. Nobody uses them any more.

Unfortunately, the client now insisted on proper brass screws for the cabinet hinges instead of the brass coloured pozidrives I was hoping to get away with.

The 1/4" chisel did not let me down! Firm, quick, precise. What more can you ask?

Test 4 - Stealability

The final test is probably the most important. I was going off the job for a couple of days as the plumber hadn't turned up. I picked my spot carefully. The box of chisels was left slightly covered but still clearly visible and propped open in the corner of the hallway where it could not fail to be seen by any of the dozen or so tradesmen and labourers working on site.

Two days later - they were still there!!!

Not only that, but no-one had even 'borrowed' them!

That is surely the ultimate in a tool for a working carpenter. Does the job but no-one wants to nick it!


All in all, I can heartily recommend the Screwfix set of chisels.

Next week, I will be reveiwing the 'Blue Spot' claw hammer.

Cheers
Brad
 
:lol: :lol: :lol:

Nice one, getting worried it was going to be a serious hand tool report :shock:
 
Brad

That is indeed a very nice metal case. Does it come in different colours?

The review lacked information as to whether these were right handed or left handed chisels. Can you please comment?

One last point - you did not provide a recommendation. Would you buy these chisels, and for whom?

Regards from Perth

Derek

p.s. nice review :lol:
 
Actually, Jacob, they are far from useless.

OK, I was having a bit of a larf with the review but I did actually buy a set of these and for everday 'butchers' chisels they are absolutely superb.

They 'hold an edge' just as well as more expensive ones and I can discern absolutely no difference in performance between these and the Bahcos for joinery jobs like morticing hinges in softwoods (although I prefer to use a Fein!)

They are actually better than the set of Stanleys I had previously - which were pinched off a job!

Cheers
Brad
 
Brad, sorry. If you are going to do a chisel review you really must include their ability to lift nails. The one I use has developed a very nice "v" shape in the centre of the edge but this took far to long to achieve.

Andy
 
I am outraged at the sheer profligacy of this Brad Naylor character. Doesn't he realise that not all of us can get to Screwedfix in Stockport and that for the average woodbutcher the more appropriately-priced Lidl 4-chisel set (last on offer at £5.99) is about as far as the budget will stretch?

Scrit :wink:
 
Alf":2kga7xy3 said:
Beautiful, Brad, just beautiful. =D> =D> =D> =D> :lol:

Cheers, Alf


Thank you Alf.

I notice you've not put it in your Hand Tool Review Links yet.

In your own time, Alf! :lol:

Cheers
Brad
 
Incidently, I've been using a similar set of budget SCREWDRIVERS, and was amazed to find them almost as good as your chisels when I put them through your review test. The advantage of screwdrivers over chisels is that you obviously never have to sharpen them :wink: :lol:
Great review brad,
Philly :lol:
 
Brad Naylor":2wfj2zou said:
I notice you've not put it in your Hand Tool Review Links yet.

In your own time, Alf! :lol:
Hah, you laugh but as it happens I was just going to ask if there were any other reviews on the board I'd overlooked that I should be adding in at the same time as this one. Anyone? I'll accept deadly serious ones too, btw... :D

Cheers, Alf
 
dedee":2eocxcs5 said:
Brad, sorry. If you are going to do a chisel review you really must include their ability to lift nails. The one I use has developed a very nice "v" shape in the centre of the edge but this took far to long to achieve.

Andy

Sorry Andy,

You are quite right. Next time I review chisels this important function will receive full coverage, along with their ability to open those really tough plastic packs of hardware from B&Q.


Paul Kierstead":2eocxcs5 said:
I am seriously disappointed at the lack of a paint-can test. What sort of chisel review doesn't include that?

Paul,

I thought I'd covered that:

I":2eocxcs5 said:
From the moment I placed the blade under the rim of the can lid I had no doubts. A firm twist of the wrist and the lid flew a good 5 feet across the room. Who says the Chinese can't produce quality goods?

Thanks for all the PM's, guys!
This Hand Tools forum isn't such a strange and unfriendly place after all. :lol: :lol:

Cheers
Brad
 
Goodness, quite right, you did indeed have it covered. I missed it! The blister pack test would be a good one to add.

Wierd, never though of using a chisel to lift nails. It would let you get right under there too....

As an aside, I have repeatedly seen cases where if you want a nice aluminum case, you are better served buying something in one and tossing the contents. Poker chip sets, for example.
 
sounds like half the things you buy in blister packs, after opening the pack is still more use than the goods, and probably more expensive too :twisted: :lol:

paul :wink:
 
How do these perform in assisting the removal of splinters?
Is there any other contenders for the swiss army chisel of the year award?
 
Back
Top