rafezetter":1fmsduv9 said:
A lot of you have posted about how you buy the "most accurate" tape measure.... accurate against what?
I have 3 tape measures, and I've never bothered to check them against each other because I use one simple rule.... for each job I just use THE SAME tape measure. It's a relative measurement after all. For some work I don't even use a measure at all but a story stick.
If you work with others I guess the only option is to make sure you all use the same brand - and compare them.
Using just one tape measure is a very good practice. Using a story stick is just as good and maybe less prone to reading error. It's easy to compare tapes if you work with others.
In answer to your question, you don't need to specify "accurate against what", as the only meaning of accuracy is absolute. A ruler is compared against the definition of a metre, which is "the length of the path travelled by light in vacuum during a time interval of 1/299,792,458 of a second." Since this is a tad inconvenient to do in the workshop, the practical method is to compare it with a standard, which is itself calibrated against a standard and so on back to one of the few National Labs (NPL, NIST, PTB etc) that is equipped to make a measurement against the velocity of light. The system must be "traceable", i..e. at every step the tolerance of the comparison must be specified and these tolerances summed to give the tolerance of the final measurement. And in manufacturing industry you must repeat the measurements every year on all your measuring equipment to be able to call yourself ISO9000 certified. And this is not just bureaucracy or academic fussiness. A firm I was associated with supplied some parts to a customer who alleged that they were out of tolerance according to their incoming measurements. The response was "our instruments have a certified accuracy, do yours?" They didn't!
The Tape Store publishes a table of the tolerances that are guaranteed in tapes of various lengths:
https://www.thetapestore.co.uk/tapes-ru ... e-measures
In my shop I have a 600 mm vertical vernier gauge that was calibrated when I bought it in a sale from a closing-down aircraft company, and which I have checked against calibrated slip gauges. I use it occasionally to check tape and other measures. The three Class 1 Advent tapes that I use are within spec, though you can still see the differences between them and the calibrated scale. It is the printing process that causes the error. Engraved steel rules are usually the best, even if not classified. A bargain-price new 600 mm vernier from Silverline was so far out that I couldn't use it.
Just in case anyone thinks this is too anal, I do have a need for absolute measurements, since I measure woodwind musical instruments to calculate their resonant frequencies. An error of 0.5 mm/m is significant (meaning that a musician can hear the difference in pitch). Hence the reason for getting class 1 tapes and checking them against a calibrated standard.
I guess only Bugbear and I are really interested in this stuff!
Keith