chaoticbob
Established Member
I'm building a picnic bench to a design based on plans on the internet and onerous (but obviously necessary) researches in the gardens of local pubs. First time I've done anything like this, so please bear with me if my questions are naive!
This is where I'm at with the frame (a test bolt-up):
As it stands, the frame 'racks' slightly if pushed from the end - I guess that's to be expected, and I imagine it will be much more rigid when the top goes on and completes the triangles formed by the diagonal braces and the A frames. My worry is that the flanges on the ends of the diagonal braces are just butt joints secured by two 70mm deck screws. Any racking forces are going to try those joints. My gut feeling is that this a very weak spot in the design, especially as the screws go into (almost) end grain, although internet plans and observations tell me it's done like this.
So questions are: (a) am I worrying about nothing, and (b) if not, any suggestions for improving the design?
I should say that if this was going in my back garden I wouldn't worry, but it's destined for a public space so need to be proof against abuse.
Robin
This is where I'm at with the frame (a test bolt-up):
As it stands, the frame 'racks' slightly if pushed from the end - I guess that's to be expected, and I imagine it will be much more rigid when the top goes on and completes the triangles formed by the diagonal braces and the A frames. My worry is that the flanges on the ends of the diagonal braces are just butt joints secured by two 70mm deck screws. Any racking forces are going to try those joints. My gut feeling is that this a very weak spot in the design, especially as the screws go into (almost) end grain, although internet plans and observations tell me it's done like this.
So questions are: (a) am I worrying about nothing, and (b) if not, any suggestions for improving the design?
I should say that if this was going in my back garden I wouldn't worry, but it's destined for a public space so need to be proof against abuse.
Robin