Is larch an acceptable alternative to cedar?

[OldWood]

I've got a beehive roof to rebuild; I reckon the cedar on it has lasted 40 years of my ownership and maybe another 40 years of the previous owner. The rebuild should again be cedar, but I'm not sure about my access to any planked cedar but can get larch locally - would that do for the 20 more years I might survive (might only be 5 months if that stupid old American guy is right !!)

Rob

 

[SurreyHills]

Yes, it should be OK. The nice thing about WRC is the weight (about 50% lighter than most other woods) which for some beekeepers is important. You should treat the wood with either Linseed oil or if you are not too concerned Cuprinol (it has a new formula that has not been "certified" bee safe).

 

[marcros]

I've got a beehive roof to rebuild; I reckon the cedar on it has lasted 40 years of my ownership and maybe another 40 years of the previous owner. The rebuild should again be cedar, but I'm not sure about my access to any planked cedar but can get larch locally - would that do for the 20 more years I might survive (might only be 5 months if that stupid old American guy is right !!)

Rob

Rob,

For a change, something that I know about. For beehives, cedar has the advantage of being light in weight/density, and not requiring treating against the elements. For a roof material, you can get away with other materials, assuming that it is going to be covered over. I would suggest wbp plywoor is as good as anything for the top of the roof, and larch will be fine for the sides. The disadvantage of planked timber on top is that it has to be much thicker than ply and therefore heavier than the ply equivalent- I personally would rather have a lighter roof with a brick on it to stop the wind blowing it off, than a heavy roof which is a pain to handle. The large manufacturers tend to use OSB.

Mark

 

[Benchwayze]

How much cedarwood do you need Rob?

If it's just one hive, and you don't mind biscuiting some widths together, I might be able to find some suitable cedar offcuts.

John