I made a box

UKworkshop.co.uk

Help Support UKworkshop.co.uk:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

bobscarle

Established Member
Joined
14 Feb 2006
Messages
506
Reaction score
0
Location
Redditch
I feel a little foolish showing a small box that I made hoping that it will sit with projects such as Woodbloke's amazing cabinet. Still here goes.

I set out to make a small box to practice hand cut dovetails. That was my only design choice other than it was to be made from material I had available. So the sides are made of beech and the top is walnut. The knob is a piece of beech turned by me. I had the hinges but no brass screws, I will replace the steel ones later.

There were several lessons learnt from making the box. Firstly, it is possible! That may seem a stupid thing to say but I have been put off hand cutting dovetails by making a mess in the past. Time and care are what I needed most of all.

The wood needs to be flat and square, something I have also neglected in the past. I planned the sides flat and shot the ends square. That made a big difference.

Tools need to be sharp! Again, I know it may seem stupid, but in the past I have tried to cut dovetails with a dull edge. I used two chisels and stropped both before starting an end and before the final finishing cut.

One thing I have yet to learn is to stop before the scribe line. You can see that there are several "holes" by the pins. These have been caused by the saw cutting just below the line usually on the back. I must do better on this next time.

Aside from the initial preparation of the wood, all the work was done by hand, except one other bit. I have always had and used a router with a lot of success. I hated using it on this project! Maybe it was that it had the capacity to destroy all my work in seconds, or maybe a powertool seemed out of place after so much hand work. OK, getting heavy, stop now!

box2.jpg


box3.jpg


OK, its not a masterpiece but it is a functional box. I still have lots more to learn but this has given me the confidence to have another go and hopefully achieve better results.
 
Looks pretty good \:D/

It might be small, but it has done well in achieving you aim of the dovetails.
Well done.
:D
 
How on earth can this be foolish? You have achieved perfect dovetails! I tried to hand cut dove tails once.... less said!

My only comment is the knob, it's a little distracting.
 
nice box Bob - don't believe that size is everything! I like the look of your box, but think it would be better without the handle but a finger hollow in the front face???......Says he that hasn't made a single box yet (if you ignore MDF)!

My wife wants me to make her a box but cannot tell me what for, so without a design brief it's pretty difficult to size one :(

Somewhere in the garage I have a number of sheets of very nice veneer (can't even remember what other than it's two types that looked good together and a bargain on fleabay). They are flat and captive between a screwed MDF sandwich waiting for thatinspirational moment.....it may be some time!
 
Bob - nice little box, dovetails look sound, agree about the comment ref the knob...a small finger pull would have looked better - Rob
 
Hi Bob,

There is nothing wrong with the size of the box, like most people I might have chosen a different approach to the knob.

But it's a really good piece of work.

Thanks for showing it.

Dave
 
my 1st thought - nice box !

2nd thought, I'd have put the knob on top in the center.

good work all the same :)
 
Thank you all for your comments and words of encouragement. They really are most appreciated.

WiZer":2f8s8f33 said:
I tried to hand cut dove tails once.... less said!
That was my initial point. I had tried and been put off by the results. I wanted to hand cut the dovetails as opposed to using a router and jig. In fact I do have an SIP jig gathering dust (anybody want it?) that I have not been able to master.

It is very interesting to hear the thoughts on the knob. I thought that it would contrast nicely with the walnut top. This is obviously not the consensus. :cry:

A finger pull has been suggested. Can I ask what would be the best way to do that? Do you shape the front of the box, the lid or both? And what with, a gouge, router, rasp or some other tool I have yet to buy?

Bob
 
Very nice box Bob and the DTs look good too. :D
I gave up on cutting DTs by hand after many many attempts.
I think the knob would look good if it was smaller,same sort of shape,but smaller.
 
Hi bobscarle,
Congratulations on the quality of the dovetails, not easy to master at first, but as you so rightly say, taking time helps.
I particularly like the contrast between the light and the dark wood.
I agree with Paul J about the knob being the same shape but smaller.
Keep up the good work

Malc :lol:
 
bobscarle wrote:
A finger pull has been suggested. Can I ask what would be the best way to do that? Do you shape the front of the box, the lid or both? And what with, a gouge, router, rasp or some other tool I have yet to buy?
Lots of ways of doing a finger pull. One way is to use a half round cutter in a router and rout both the lid and the box along join or just the lid itself. The other option is to use a small gouge to carve a depression somewhere and then finish with a HSS hacksaw blade ground to the profile and then used as a scraper, then sandpaper. Alternatively, if your gouge is razor sharp you can leave the gouge marks in the wood and have a finish straight from the edge. The thing about doing it by hand is that you can carve any shape pull you like...an oval say, which you can't do with a router - Rob
 
Nice work, Bob. The problems you've encountered here are things that you will over come with in time with practice - so, keep at it, everyone makes mistakes! Let's see your next piece when you're ready! :wink: :D
 
putting our knobs aside, (HA HA BOOM BOOM!), the dovetails look great, it's amazing how much they clean up when you start sanding etc. Mine always look rough till then

Aidan
 
Back
Top