Trevanion":3n1tvx3m said:
Jacob":3n1tvx3m said:
I used them all the time on every job when I was into period joinery. Indispensable.
On
EVERY job? I can see their merit with some things as I mentioned above but I think marking out onto a piece of MDF to only transfer those marks onto the workpiece only
once is a massive waste of time, you may as well just mark the workpiece from the get-go and get on with it.
How many workpieces are so unique to a job that they are more easily marked up directly?
At a glance I'd say about zero.
No doubt the odd exception but I can't think of an example off hand.
A table has four legs. A drawer has 4 sides, 1 bottom, 2 slips. A set of sash windows could have hundreds of components with identical marks, or marks which relate to other components. I made a little chest of 4 drawers recently - a rough count says about 34 components - all related to each other, non of them unique (except the top, which also has to relate to everything else and needs to be on the rod). Not to mark them up from a rod would be insane. You'd spend hours fiddling with a tape and lists of measurements, calculations, corrections. Madness, bin there dunnit, made the mistakes, filled out the mortices out by 10mm, thrown away stuff cut too short, etc etc.
PS not just the construction details but you can put in the hardware, position of knobs, all sorts of other stuff, everything which needs to be done shown in exactly the right position.