The future of planes?

UKworkshop.co.uk

Help Support UKworkshop.co.uk:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

rafezetter

Troll Hunter
Joined
11 Jun 2013
Messages
3,058
Reaction score
336
Location
Here
A google walkabout brought me to this site; could this be the future of handplanes? Personally I love it, akin to a prototype supercar, and if cash allowed I'd buy it, although the "call for price" means it's probably really shocking; and the depth skids have given me a bit of an idea....

http://www.bridgecitytools.com/defa...ols/ct-18-dual-low-angle-smoothing-plane.html

Edit - a bit more googling has found the price $1796... £1,152 eek!
 
wow, looks cool, a bit to futuristic for my taste and way to expensive, so maby in 100yr ill pick one up cheap at a boot fair :)

who will be getting this plane??
TT
 
I'm sure it will sell well and I wouldn't be surprised if there is a short period when the first few sell on for even more than the list price.


What I think is more interesting than the appearance and the price is the promise that with this plane you can do high precision work, making multiple parts, identically sized to a thousandth of an inch. That is the logical end of machine woodworking, with CNC cut components which can be selected at random and fitted together perfectly.

But aiming for that with hand tools ignores the fact that there is a well established way to go about making things which achieves accuracy where it is needed, as the job proceeds. So you mark components together, and establish a face side and face edge. That way you get the inside of a carcase exactly square. (The outside is less crucial. )

You then make the doors or drawers a little over size and plane them to fit. The actual, numerical size doesn't really matter. Precision comes in fitting one part to another.


(Incidentally the idea of fitting skids is not new (they don't claim that it is). Stanley produced a plane fitted with a depth limiting frame for planing weaving shuttles to exact size in the 1880s.

Robert Wearing also mentioned the idea in at least one of his books.
 
What a truly awful, cold looking Plane. It belongs on the end of a CNC machine. Where it should stay.
 
Thats sleek. Its a piece of Art - like a Bugatti Veyron.

I doubt the majority of them will even touch a piece of wood. Holed-up in cabinets like some coveted old planes, are... A shame really.
 
No sorry! The wacky world of "Vanity Planes" don't float my boat, but if it is a prototype which in future will lead to a high precession item retailing at £20 I'm all for it, provided they rework the handle/tote to something more user friendly.

G
 
woodbrains":25fi2969 said:
Grayorm":25fi2969 said:
Wouldn't fit in my toolbox :lol: If I were going to spen £2k on a plane it would be on one of these. Have a look at them all some gorgeous stuff. http://www.holteyplanes.com/

Hello,

If you had about £2K to spend, you'd only have a small deposit for that! :shock:

Mike.

Yeowch! Not looked at his prices for a while.
 
Wow! So judgemental. Aren't people free to spend their own money any way they like?

I think it's a great that there's so much innovation happening with woodworking tools. I'd much rather be a woodworker today than in the dark days of the 1970's, when quality was being driven ever further down.

The only single legitimate concern I can see is the risk that a beginner might think this kind of exotic kit is somehow needed to produce quality work, but with the publicity surrounding Narex and Quangsheng I doubt that's really likely.
 
Grayorm":d481zop0 said:
Wouldn't fit in my toolbox :lol: If I were going to spen £2k on a plane it would be on one of these. Have a look at them all some gorgeous stuff. http://www.holteyplanes.com/

holy (bleep) £7,380 inc vat? that's a car!! - It's a work of art too but...seriously - who buys a plane that expensive - no "working man" woodworker surely? Purely for the rich hobbyist who's tools aren't his livelihood.
 
rafezetter":2qn53i08 said:
Grayorm":2qn53i08 said:
Wouldn't fit in my toolbox :lol: If I were going to spen £2k on a plane it would be on one of these. Have a look at them all some gorgeous stuff. http://www.holteyplanes.com/

holy (bleep) £7,380 inc vat? that's a car!! - It's a work of art too but...seriously - who buys a plane that expensive - no "working man" woodworker surely? Purely for the rich hobbyist who's tools aren't his livelihood.

In a world that has £24,000 handbags, I think a 7,000 quid plane shows remarkable restraint.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article ... nfrey.html

BugBear
 
I think it's pretty cool...but somewhat overpriced for a mass ( well, maybe not mass, but certainly not bespoke..) market tool from a company that is aiming to sell a lot....as people have noted, its up there in Holtey territory , price wise. And I know what I would prefer if I was dropping over 2 large on a tool....
 
Back
Top