Best way to replicate this 'bowtie' style on vertical supports for bookshelf?

UKworkshop.co.uk

Help Support UKworkshop.co.uk:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Joined
17 Aug 2023
Messages
18
Reaction score
0
Hello,

I hope you can help point me into the right direction.

I'm trying to replicate the following bookshelf, and the vertical supports have this 'bowtie' look that I have no clue how to achieve.

I only have access to hand tools right now.

How can I achieve a similar tapered look on those vertical supports ?

Thanks again

Quentin
1692299102130.png
 
If you have only hand tools, looks like the option is to plane them? Or cut with angled saw cut and plane to finish?

(Scale is hard to be clear on from the photo so the latter may be more or less viable).
 
Depend on the tools available

Spaced crosscuts with a saw to the depth and then chisel out the waste

Central sea kerf, hog out most of waste with a cambered scrub plane across the grain and then even up with a rebate plane

Tenoning jig on a table saw with the blade inclined to the right angle

Neat sawing with a rip saw to the angles needed

If it were me I’d be tempted to laminate it with a central piece and then 4 triangles glued on
 
Hi Tom, I like your central piece + 4 triangles idea..
Jvc, Here's another picture for you.
I have no table saw, just a hand saw and a mitre guide, and a couple hand planers.


Thanks already for your feedback!
 
Last edited:
I'd be more worried about what's holding the whole thing up. There are three battens on the wall but there'd need to be some other fixings to stop it folding. Maybe hidden cantilever to the bottom shelf and everything depending on that?
It looks photoshopped anyway and not the real thing
 
Last edited:
The bowties might be sliding dovetails into the shelfs which would give it some strength
 
I'd be more worried about what's holding the whole thing up. There are three battens on the wall but there'd need to be some other fixings to stop it folding. Maybe hidden cantilever to the bottom shelf and everything depending on that?
It looks photoshopped anyway and not the real thing
I've asked the guy that build it and it's just being held by those 3 cleats if I believe him..
His installations instructions just state to slide the whole thing onto them.

Edit : 2 more pictures of the shelves
 

Attachments

  • ddsafdfa.jpg
    ddsafdfa.jpg
    71.1 KB
  • Shelves-0060-HiRes_WEB.jpg
    Shelves-0060-HiRes_WEB.jpg
    86.3 KB
They look sculpted like with a saburrtooth in an angle grinder
Thanks Tom.
Looks like I might either need some specialised tool, or a lot of sanding..

I do like the look of them better than straight pieces but I might have to reconsider.

Thanks
 
One option might be to start with a scrub plane to get the basic shape and smooth from there, or possibly a narrower plane like a shoulder or bullnose.
Not sure if a rounded spokeshave would work.
I think one of the above would be my preferred option, after some trial and error.

Another option would be a router sled that you can move across the workpiece and run the router over.
The challenge would be keeping the workpiece secure enough to be safe.

If you are meticulous, you could also use a table saw to make incremental cuts from the middle out, lowering the blade and moving the fence before cutting, turning 180 and going again. The opposing side wouldn't have much support though, so you'd need plenty of something not-the-workpiece between you and the blade!
 
The designers, Brooke Richard and Laura Watson have a studio and access to a workshop and makers. It's not clear from the website if the designers own the workshop or if the work is farmed out to a collaborative facility. I suspect, however, that those vertical pieces concave on both faces are produced on a CNC machine requiring only a little light sanding to get them polish ready. That would be almost certainly be the easiest and quickest way, although there's no technical reason they couldn't be produced by hand. Slainte.
 
They look chunkier when you look closer. Scope for some solid fixings?
Some seriously pretentious books on show! Damien Hirst: The Souls

Bookshelves — Richard Watson

Screenshot 2023-08-18 at 18.46.26.png


Making them - what about diminishing saw kerfs over the TS to pick out the curve, waste removed with chisel/plane, down to the lines, finished against a drum sander or with yer old belt sander - the bodgers favourite finishing tool?
 
Last edited:
The rasp was my first thought, but I figured the depth might be too great.
I still think it is doable with planes. It look like a fun project, I might have a go if I ever get my workbench finished (the build is almost into year 2 lol).
It will be a good excuse to buy some tools ;)
 
I'd be more worried about what's holding the whole thing up. There are three battens on the wall but there'd need to be some other fixings to stop it folding. Maybe hidden cantilever to the bottom shelf and everything depending on that?
It looks photoshopped anyway and not the real thing
I don't think it's photoshopped. The shadows are consistent with the lighting angle and position and none of the levels are identical.

There are three supporting brackets on the top, middle and bottom shelves that provide sufficient support for the structure.
 
I'm hesitant to suggest this as the OP states only hand tools are available, but an investment in a router plus a bit or two if funds are available could be a solution that reduces the amount of handwork, and probably improve consistency in the curves produced. A router could be employed to create both the joints between the vertical supports and the horizontal member, e.g., a tongue and housing or similar, and the concavity in the faces of the vertical parts.

To create the concavity, at least in basic profile, in the verticals would need a further investment in materials, e.g., softwood plus board material, plus some hardware, e.g., washers, nuts and bolts, screws, that sort of thing. These materials could be used to create a pendulum mechanism to which the router is attached allowing it to swing in an arc. Of course, this is just the kernel of a method and some ingenuity would be required by the OP to make the rig so that the radius of the swing is adjustable and the means for holding the parts firmly in place whilst being shaped. There would also be a need to create lateral movement of some sort, of either the router or the part being shaped, between swings of the router.

Going with this method is sure to be reasonably technically challenging, fairly slow, tedious, dusty and noisy, but it's not new having been done before. On the other hand, doing the job with just hand tools is also likely to be relatively slow and tedious requiring some quite good technical skills.

All the above just another option as an alternative to the obvious and simple (sic) solution of a bit of digital drafting and chucking the parts onto your basic five axis CNC machine along with its requisite dust extraction system, ha, ha. Slainte.
 
I don't think it's photoshopped. The shadows are consistent with the lighting angle and position and none of the levels are identical.

There are three supporting brackets on the top, middle and bottom shelves that provide sufficient support for the structure.
I see no brackets, unless the partitions at each and of the battens are firmly fixed to the battens themselves, to function as brackets. Even then the bottom shelf is just hanging from the partitions with no support from below.
 
Last edited:
I see no brackets, unless the partitions at each and of the battens are firmly fixed to the battens themselves, to function as brackets. Even then the bottom shelf is just hanging from the partitions with no support from below.
Are wee looking at the same image? The first image posted by the OP shows 3 shelves with 3 supports, one under the centre area of each shelf pair. Plenty of support there.
 
Are wee looking at the same image? The first image posted by the OP shows 3 shelves with 3 supports, one under the centre area of each shelf pair. Plenty of support there.
6 shelves. Only battens on the wall, no brackets. OK if the partitions are fixed solid to each shelf, above and below, but how would they do that?
I just wondered how it would stand up to a full load of books.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top