Assistance in choosing tools

UKworkshop.co.uk

Help Support UKworkshop.co.uk:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

JayStout

New member
Joined
2 May 2015
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Location
Aberdeen
Good afternoon all,

I'm looking for some assistance in choosing my first set of tools; I plan on doing some box-making to begin with but with the plethora of hand tools out there the choice is a little daunting. Realistically I'm looking for a sweet spot of quality against affordability. I've had a look through the review thread that is stickied in this forum and although there's quite a lot that I'd like to purchase, I'm looking to avoid shiny box syndrome as I could go and buy tools that I'll have no immediate use for.

Any recommendations and direction pointing would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks,
John
 
Hello John, and welcome to the forum!

Whilst you ask a very sensible question, it's not an easy one to answer simply. There are several reasons for this; it depends what you want to do, and whether you want to go handtool only or handtool supported by some power tools or machines. It also depends on whether you're prepared to fettle up secondhand tools, or you'd rather start off with something decent that works without too much 'bothering'.

Something that may help is a book. Specifically, 'The Anarchists Tool Chest' by Christopher Schwarz, which sets out the tools he's found by experience to be most useful for someone wanting to make 'proper' furniture and such items at home, and what to look for in each tool. (There's more to the book, too - how to build a cabinetmaker's tool chest, which might not be of immediate relevance, but may provide food for thought in due course.) The book isn't available through Amazon, but UK buyers can purchase a copy here - http://www.classichandtools.com/acatalo ... Press.html - scroll down the page, and it's near the bottom. Whilst you're there, buy a copy of 'The Essential Woodworker' by Robert Wearing, which is a great introduction to things like how to plane wood up square and flat, how to make simple tables, stools, basic cabinets and so on. Neither book is 'cheap', but they're beautifully produced and the information is priceless.

One basic tool is a bench. Doesn't have to be anything fancy, just rigid and preferably heavy (or firmly fixed to something solid). Indeed, it's best if a mark 1 bench isn't perfect - the lessons learned will inform a much better mark 2 when the time comes.

For getting started, not very much is needed. A couple of hardpoint saws (a hand saw and a backsaw), a try-square, a drill and some drillbits, a hammer, a mallet, screwdrivers, a tape measure and a steel rule, a plane of either No 4 or No 5 size, a few chisels and a means to sharpen plane iron and chisels will get you going. Then at the start of each project, decide what additional tools you need, and buy them then. That will avoid the pitfall of buying stuff you end up never using. Oh - and you'll need some pencils, a packet of sticking plasters, and a dustpan and brush!

Perhaps the most difficult purchase is a first plane. It needs to be a good one, to avoid the problem of having to fettle it, and there are a couple of ways to stack the cards in your favour and avoid the rubbish. First, if it seems too cheap to be true, it probably is - you can buy new planes for £20 or so - don't! If you can afford it, buying premium (Lie-Nielsen, Clifton or Veritas) will give a lifetime tool that'll work straight out of the box - at a price. There are also the better Chinese imports - Wood River and Quangsheng - which are almost as good but not as costly. Then there's the option of buying a good secondhand user from one of the better secondhand dealers (Ray Iles of The Old Tool Store offers refurbished planes, which will be a sound investment). Finally, you can take your chances with the likes of Ebay, from which it's possible to find really first-class planes at bargain prices, but from which many a dog has surfaced, too. It's a bit of a lottery unless you have some knowledge of what you're looking at.

Don't worry about making one or two mistakes, though. We all have a few we'd rather not admit to, and it all adds to experience!
 
Thanks for the input gents, it's much appreciated. G S Haydon, I'll read the blog post after work - unfortunately 'personal sites' are blocked behind my company's firewall.
 
Paul Sellers blog entries "ten tools three joints" is worth a read http://paulsellers.com/2014/05/question ... ee-joints/. There are plenty of other tools you are going to want if you keep woodworking but this will get you going.
As far as makes are concerned if you want to buy new then narex for chisels (or aldi/lidl when available), quangsheng for planes and veritas for saws, all offer good value. Otherwise go for old tools from ebay, which will involve some work and probably some mistakes but may help you learn more about the tools than buying new.
Whist reading sellers check out his "build a workbench" series
Good luck, Paddy
 
Something I forgot in my screed above was cramps - or clamps. It's sometimes said that you can never have too many cramps. I'm not so sure - when I first joined this forum, I asked what others recommended as a fair kit, and was mildly surprised how few even quite experienced workers owned. One factor is that a lot of occasional clamping tasks can be accomplished by shop-made 'wangles' or simple devices built from scraps. Another is that having a lot of cramps is just a storage problem most of the time.

However, some cramps are almost essential. I find that the most-used in my workshop are a set of four 6" F-cramps, and a set of four 3" G-cramps. Next in line are four 12" F-cramps, and a couple of sets of Record sash cramps, four off each 18" and 48". That lot amounts to quite an investment, and the sash cramps could be replaced by cramp-heads and shop-made battens.

What's most useful does, of course, depend on what work you do. If starting over, I'd definitely buy the 6" F-cramps and 3" G-cramps, and I'd buy the best I could find. Then I'd add others as projects and experience suggested.
 
Well I have two projects I'm currently thinking about (outside of the usual such as building the first bench although as stated above I don't really have a great deal of space at the moment so might need to start with a Black and Decker Workmate or similar):

- a knitting box/chest. A friend of mine is headed to Africa to help build some wells for communities there. She's just got into knitting, so I thought a box made of African woods might be a good idea.
- a nursing stool. An old friend has recently learnt he is going to become a father and as I'm from an old school community, I figured a hand-built nursing stool would be a good gift.

Of course, I plan to build some test pieces first before jumping straight in to the actual projects.
 
Beware of African wood. The reversing grain on many African timbers can be a nightmare to hand plane due to reversing grain. I recently used a load of iroko left over from a boat deck to make a bed and found it really hard to hand plane with no tearout. If you do want to use African hard woods I would definitely recommend a no. 80 cabinet scraper (or a belt sander).
Paddy
 
Cheshirechappie":2i8hz3df said:
Something I forgot in my screed above was cramps - or clamps. It's sometimes said that you can never have too many cramps.

Thinking about my investment in clamps gives me stomach cramps.
 
Back
Top