Two for critique
- Thread starter RATWOOD
- Start date
Help Support UKworkshop.co.uk:
Bodrighy
Established Member
How do you Tie dye wood? Seriously I like the colouring a lot. Not the sort of thing you see much of but it works for me,
Pete
Pete
CHJ
Established Member
I too like the colouring, achieved the ragged look but with a clean un-smudged muddied result, not so sure about what appears to be a stoppered hole in No. One, which looks more like Beech than Ash, bowl/rim proportions work for me.
No.two, I like the idea but seems a little heavy to me, don't know if it's the dense colouring on the rim, I think the upper rim undercut could stand a cleanup to remove stain bleed and tool? marks. Guess that may be difficult now your mountings removed.
No.two, I like the idea but seems a little heavy to me, don't know if it's the dense colouring on the rim, I think the upper rim undercut could stand a cleanup to remove stain bleed and tool? marks. Guess that may be difficult now your mountings removed.
The Shark
Established Member
Hi Chris,
They are both very impressive
Malc
They are both very impressive
Malc
Jenx
Established Member
- Joined
- 27 Sep 2007
- Messages
- 1,978
- Reaction score
- 0
Hi Chris ... !
Both look really great, and I especially like the first one.. the colouring is a really nice effect !
Brilliant !
Both look really great, and I especially like the first one.. the colouring is a really nice effect !
Brilliant !
Paul.J
Established Member
Very nicely done Chris
The first i would say was Beech also.
Nicely sized rim on this one and looks well in proportion to the bowl,but i would like to have seen a bigger outer rim on No2,or smaller inner rim.
Just doesn't look in proportion to me.
Like the staining on two better
The first i would say was Beech also.
Nicely sized rim on this one and looks well in proportion to the bowl,but i would like to have seen a bigger outer rim on No2,or smaller inner rim.
Just doesn't look in proportion to me.
Like the staining on two better
mikec
Established Member
Very good staining technique on No1 Chris. How did you achieve such a "clean" look. Not sure about the proportions on No2, purely personal , but again the staining technique is good.
Mike C
Mike C
kasandrich
Established Member
I like both bowls, very nice work, I am not a big fan of colouring, the black rim I could live with but I do not like the multi-coloured parts. I can appreciate the craftmanship of doing it, it is a very laborious task and very difficult to get it looking even yet random, so well done in what you were trying to achieve, and I can see many people loving it, but not for me.
The only criticism I could make of the work is that the line could have been cleaned up on the multicoloured finish on bowl 2.
The only criticism I could make of the work is that the line could have been cleaned up on the multicoloured finish on bowl 2.
Similar threads
